"If You Show Me Yours I'll Show You Mine" - Screenplay Review

From the very first page of Riya Agarwal's 24-page screenplay, I found myself drawn into a world that feels authentically teenage – complete with all its awkwardness, curiosity, and misguided attempts at appearing grown-up. What particularly captivated me was how the story took me back to my own childhood memories of desperately wanting to seem more mature than I was, while being completely unprepared for actual maturity.

Reading this screenplay was a delightful experience, primarily because of how genuine every character interaction feels. I found myself laughing out loud at Niki's hilariously innocent understanding of pregnancy – her conviction that Clarissa, a 7th grader, needed President Bush's approval for a baby is the kind of misconception that feels so real, it must have been inspired by true childhood confusion. These moments of pure innocence created such a wonderful contrast with the characters' attempts to appear worldly and mature.

The egg-throwing birthday scene particularly resonated with me. There's something so perfectly teenage about it – the mixture of friendship, slight humiliation, and pure joy that defines those early teenage years. I could practically hear the squeals and laughter, smell the raw eggs, and feel the sticky mess. It's these kinds of sensory details that made the screenplay come alive in my imagination.

What I appreciated most was how each character seemed to jump off the page with such a distinct personality, making them feel real and relatable. Niki’s friend group, for instance, reminded me of actual middle school girls I might have known – especially Mekhola, whose comment about Niki being ‘deep in some Illuminati shit’ made me snort with laughter (embarrassing, I know). It’s exactly the kind of pseudo-sophisticated thing a teenage girl would say to sound worldly, and it added to the authentic feel of their interactions.

Niki herself is brilliantly written, with her mix of innocence and rebellious energy capturing that delicate, thrilling moment on the edge of adolescence. Her banter with her older brother Adam felt so real and relatable; Adam, as the responsible yet curious brother, balances Niki perfectly with his own mix of protectiveness and an occasional willingness to bend the rules.

Then there’s Obi, the ‘cool uncle’ figure – his dynamic with Niki is both endearing and, at times, uncomfortable. While he encourages the kids’ mischief and treats them as equals, his role as an adult sometimes blurs boundaries, especially in moments when he tries to ‘show Niki reality.’ It’s a line that risks being crossed, giving the story a layer of tension that examines the impact of adult influence on a young, impressionable child.

Maya, Niki’s feisty and protective mother, is another standout, epitomizing the immigrant mother striving to uphold her cultural values while trying to protect her children from the fast-paced American adolescence around them. Her distance from Niki, a result of generational and cultural differences, adds depth to the family dynamics and highlights the screenplay’s theme of balancing protection with freedom in a way that resonated deeply.

What impressed me most was how the screenplay built tension in unexpected ways. The DVD store sequence is a perfect example. As a reader, I initially felt almost frustrated by how easily Niki obtained the R-rated movie – it seemed too simple, too convenient. Then came the brilliant twist with Guy's father appearing, launching into a chase sequence that had me on the edge of my seat for a few moments. This kind of masterful misdirection kept me engaged throughout the entire read.

While reading, I did find myself growing increasingly uncomfortable during the scenes between Niki and her uncle Obi, particularly in his bedroom. While I understand the writer's intent to explore the boundaries between mentorship and overstepping, these moments pushed me out of my comfort zone as a reader. The scene, while well-written, left me with a sense of unease that I believe stretched beyond the intended exploration of innocence versus maturity.

What truly amazed me was how much story Agarwal packed into just 24 pages. Every scene felt necessary, every line of dialogue served a purpose, and yet nothing felt rushed or underdeveloped. The economy of storytelling here is remarkable – as a reader, I never felt like I was missing information, despite the screenplay's brevity.

Reading "If You Show Me Yours I'll Show You Mine" was like watching a high-wire act – a delicate balance between innocence and maturity, protection and freedom. While certain scenes pushed boundaries more than I was comfortable with, the overall experience was engaging and thought-provoking.

What will stay with me most is how perfectly Agarwal captured that peculiar moment in adolescence when we're desperate to grow up but completely unprepared for what that actually means. Through Niki's journey, she reminds us all of that confusing, exciting, and sometimes dangerous transition from childhood to adolescence – a reminder that growing up is never as simple as we think it will be when we're young.

-----